I was wondering if anyone has used Scratch with a class of children- probably aged 9-11. I was wondering what, if any, misconceptions the children had either before or while using the game.
Thank you for your help.
Naomi
Replies
Bernd Gärtner
Member
April 18, 2012
The most frequent misconception that I encountered is that the "if" block is expected to work like a "forever if" block. It is not clear to many children that an "if" checks its condition only once, so it does not wait until the condition occurs. I have introduced special exercises to deal with this.
Bernd.
Amanda Ford
Member
April 05, 2012
Hi Naomi
Not sure how helpful I can be but I have worked with a few classes now over the past 3 years (as a researcher not a teacher but leading the lessons), The only things I have noticed are :
The children may think that when you ask a sprite to "say something" it will literally say it and are dissappinted when the text comes up.
The children are surprised when I learn from them. Sometimes I have discovered little parts of Scratch things that I didnt know through the children.
On the other hand children get surprised when I say I will have to go away to find out what they have asked me and come back to them the following week with an answer to their problem.
Amanda
Naomi Goff
Member
April 06, 2012
Amanda,
Thank you for your response. I also experienced the second two comments that you mentioned. There is so much to learn from scratch and I found that children were much more willing to explore and try out different commands to see what happened with them.
I am a student teacher and we taught scratch to a class of year 5's, they loved it, and I learnt so much more about the software.
The most frequent misconception that I encountered is that the "if" block is expected to work like a "forever if" block. It is not clear to many children that an "if" checks its condition only once, so it does not wait until the condition occurs. I have introduced special exercises to deal with this.
Bernd.
Hi Naomi
Not sure how helpful I can be but I have worked with a few classes now over the past 3 years (as a researcher not a teacher but leading the lessons), The only things I have noticed are :
The children may think that when you ask a sprite to "say something" it will literally say it and are dissappinted when the text comes up.
The children are surprised when I learn from them. Sometimes I have discovered little parts of Scratch things that I didnt know through the children.
On the other hand children get surprised when I say I will have to go away to find out what they have asked me and come back to them the following week with an answer to their problem.
Amanda
Amanda,
Thank you for your response. I also experienced the second two comments that you mentioned. There is so much to learn from scratch and I found that children were much more willing to explore and try out different commands to see what happened with them.
I am a student teacher and we taught scratch to a class of year 5's, they loved it, and I learnt so much more about the software.
Thank you again.
Naomi